logo

30 pages 1 hour read

Leaf by Niggle

Fiction | Short Story | Adult | Published in 1945

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character Analysis

Niggle

Niggle is designed as a relatable character, described as being a “little man” who was “kind hearted in a way” (87). Niggle’s disposition is that of someone who is inclined to be selfish, yet knows it is wrong to do so. This internal struggle is what makes his journey so compelling. On the one hand, Niggle should be able to complete his painting before his long journey, given that this painting is very important to him. Yet, on the other hand, Mr. Parish needs his help, and the law strictly says that neighbors are required to help each other in times of need. Seeing this internal struggle is relatable to many people, as it is in human nature to want to prioritize one’s own selfish interests.

Niggle’s artistic proclivity is also important to the story as well. Throughout the piece, Niggle’s creativity is hidden, and those around him only see his canvas as construction material. The Home Inspector, Tompkins, and even Mr. Parish only see the use of Niggle’s picture, rather than the beauty of it. As a result, Niggle’s artistic talents often get overlooked, until the very end when Mr. Parish and Niggle finally come to realize the value of each other’s expertise. The way Niggle’s strengths are overlooked symbolizes the way beauty and art are often overlooked and undervalued in a modern world where money and productivity are considered the only items of value. Yet, as Niggle and Mr. Parish find out, art and beauty are what make life worth living.

Mr. Parish

Mr. Parish is introduced as Niggle’s neighbor, who was his “only real neighbor” (91) because the others lived a long way off. Niggle also does not like Mr. Parish because he “did not like painting but was very critical of gardening” (91). Readers are not able to hear the thoughts of Mr. Parish like they can for Niggle, but the text seems to indicate Mr. Parish thinks Niggle’s painting is a waste of time and not productive. This feeling is indicated when Mr. Parish comes to call for help and says, “You are very busy, I’m sure” (91), adding the last part as almost a sarcastic remark, though perhaps he did not mean for it to come off that way. Nevertheless, Mr. Parish, like many other in the countryside, prefers practicality over creativity, which puts the two men at odds with one another.

Yet, despite their differences, they learn to help one other after Niggle’s long journey. While Niggle is dreaming and imagining different plants for their newly constructed house, Niggle learns that Mr. Parish “always knew exactly how to set them and where they would do best” (107). From this exchange, the reader learns that Mr. Parish is more than just a needy neighbor, but rather a friend with a wealth of practical knowledge. This shows how, given the proper communication between the two men, their differences complement the other. Mr. Parish’s character provides balance to Niggle’s creativity and at-times self-absorbed tendencies, and in the end, we see how, with a little humility, Mr. Parish comes to appreciate the beauty Niggle adds when previously Mr. Parish simply passed it off as “Niggle’s Nonsense” or “Daubing” (109).

The Driver, the Porter, and the Shepherd

The Driver and the Shepherd appear in the story as both a function and a symbol. Their functions are to guide Niggle on his journey, though he doesn’t know the details of that journey in the beginning. The Driver is the first to help Niggle depart on his journey, though his demeanor is decidedly cold and unwelcoming. When he first meets Niggle, he remarks that Niggle ought to be ready for his journey by now and can’t delay packing. The Driver states, “Well, it’s finished with, as far as you’re concerned, at any rate. Come along!” (96). Symbolically, the Driver could resemble death, which is often described as cold and unyielding much like this character, offering those whose time has run out no sympathy and no alternative way out. Given that the Driver is dressed in black and gives no other indication of his identity or his purpose, this also symbolizes the fear of the unknown as to what awaits in the afterlife. The Porter is a similar character to the Driver, in that he is there to help Niggle with his journey, and even asks Niggle where all his stuff has gone, yet he offers no helping hand nor extends no sympathy to Niggle along the way.

The Shepherd does not come in until the very end of the story: “They saw a man, he looked like a shepherd; he was walking towards them” (108). The shepherd symbolizes the Christian savior, Jesus Christ, who is referred to as the Good Shepherd tasked with bringing souls to heaven. Given that Niggle is about to embark on this last portion of his journey, it is fitting that the Shepherd guides Niggle to the mountains that represent heaven.

The First Voice and the Second Voice

The First Voice and the Second Voice are another instance of characters with very little description to help readers visualize what they look or sound like. This continues the theme of mysteriousness surrounding the characters, as both the reader and Niggle are not entirely sure what the Voices are and what they are meant to do. Niggle’s primary interaction with the First Voice and the Second Voice is just a conversation he eavesdrops on while lying in the infirmary. The stern First Voice acknowledges that the hopeful Second Voice has greater say in deciding the next step Niggle should take on his journey: “But you have the last word. It is your task, of course, to put the best interpretation on the facts” (101). Additionally, once Mr. Parish completes his journey and finds Niggle, he remarks. “I ought not to be here. I owe you!” to which Niggle replies “No, you owe it to the Second Voice. We both do” (107).

By keeping the names of the voices a secret, it is possible that Tolkien is yet again drawing parallels to the afterlife with these characters in these passages. The voices seem to be portraying two angels or perhaps the two figures in the Christian Trinity (e.g., God the Father and God the Son). The First Voice is severe and authoritative, two traits that Catholicism often associates with God the Father. The Second Voice is merciful and kind, advocating for Niggle to receive some “gentle treatment” (101). The Second Voice’s advocacy reflects the mercy God the Son shows in the Gospels.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 30 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools